Beyond Critique

This is actually a rather good presentation.

Posted in Science, Sexuality Tagged with: , ,
  • mattwardman

    An emerging area that I would welcome your opinion on is Opinion-based Sexual Orientation, which the various -ism lobbies are moving towards demanding as a right.

    This has been quite prominent in the recent pitched battle concerning Julie Birchill / Suzanne Moore and Transexuality.

    It is also quite prominent in the recent all-of-a-sudden adoption of ‘anti-harrassment’ policies by umpteen atheist groups in North America:


    which is based on this:

    It is an interestingly different argument to the now-traditional “homosexuality is genetic/not a choice”, while religion is just an opinion, so discimination against the HS community is like racism ¬†and the religious must just suck up whatever comes their way.

    The sharpest one will be whether “Genderqueer” (I choose man/woman presentation based on how I feel at any particular time) claims confer a right to impose limitations on the actions of others, since (as far as I can see anyway) there is no basis whatsoever for the existence of the orientation outside bald assertion.

    To me, if claims for allowing discrimination against religion because it is an opinion succeed, the Genderqueer claims fail the same hurdle.

    I’m not expecting consistency, however :-).

    • Peter Ould

      This kind of extreme form of post-modernistic self-determination is quite surreal. What it is essentially amounts to is “I can choose to be whatever I want to be at any particular moment and I have a right to demand you accept it and treat me as the status I choose to be”.

      And of course, it is utterly illogical and inconsistent. It’s one thing to establish over a long-term period gender dysphoria, it’s another to simply demand society flex to your daily will. I might as well turn up to someone who believed this, claim that I *am* the King and therefore they must serve me in all things.

About Peter

  • Welcome to An Exercise in the Fundamentals of Orthodoxy, the leading UK site exploring issues of Christianity and sexual identity. To find out more about Peter click here
  • Want to join the other subscribers to Peter's RSS feed? Click here.
  • Want to get in touch with Peter? Click here


Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Anglican Cycle

Christ the King
Eternal Father, whose Son Jesus Christ ascended to the throne of heaven that he might rule over all things as Lord and King: keep the Church in the unity of the Spirit and in the bond of peace, and bring the whole created order to worship at his feet; who is alive and reigns with you, in the unity of the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever.

Recent Comments

Peter on Twitter

Two Final Things

Aber mit der Heimat
geht man immer herum,
durch die Welt,
dort und dort
Peter Handke

No one could describe
the Word of the Father;
but when He took flesh from you, O Theotokos,
He consented to be described, and restored the fallen image to its former beauty.
We confess and proclaim our salvation in word and image.
Kontakion of the Triumph of Orthodoxy